Header graphic for print
Canadian Securities Regulatory Monitor News and Insight

Tag Archives: sanctions

CSA’s 2016 Enforcement Report: insights into securities regulatory activity

Posted in AMF, CSA, Enforcement, Litigation, OSC

The Canadian Securities Administrators (CSA) recently released its annual report on the enforcement activities of its members. The CSA is an umbrella group of Canada’s securities regulators.

Summary of 2016 Results[1]

Generally, enforcement and pre-enforcement activity, and monetary sanctions imposed by regulators decreased compared to 2015 but were higher than they were in 2014.

2016 2015 2014
Monetary Sanctions $62,148,866 $138,298,796 $58,239,156
Restitution, Compensation and Disgorgement $349,654,379 $111,651,429 $65,717,760
Commenced Cases (by notice of hearing, statement of allegations, or sworn Information) 56 108 105
Individual Respondents 72 165 189
Company Respondents 72 101 92
Most prevalent violations Illegal Distributions
Continue Reading

CSA 2015 Enforcement Report Reveals Increased Regulatory Activity and Significantly Higher Monetary Sanctions

Posted in CSA, Enforcement, IIROC, MFDA, OSC

On February 23, 2016, the Canadian Securities Administrators (CSA) released its annual report on the enforcement activities of its members. Enforcement and pre-enforcement activity has increased significantly in 2015. Monetary sanctions imposed by regulators more than doubled year-over-year and regulators concluded 38% more cases in 2015 even as the number of new proceedings increased slightly.

The 2015 Results

Monetary sanctions doubled: The regulators collectively imposed the highest amount of monetary sanctions on market participants since 2009, the year their investigation into the crash of the asset-backed commercial paper market was settled. In 2015, regulators imposed $138.3 … Continue Reading

The OSC Overturns IIROC Panel’s Decision with Harsher Sanctions

Posted in Enforcement, IIROC, OSC

The Ontario Securities Commission (OSC) recently imposed harsher sanctions than were ordered by a panel of Investment Industry Regulatory Organization of Canada (IIROC) following a contested proceeding. The OSC’s decision has important implications in enforcement proceedings before IIROC.

The IIROC Decision (no suspension)

After a contested hearing, an IIROC Panel determined that Lucy Lukic, a registrant at an IIROC member firm, recommended off-the-book investments to her clients.[1] Lukic had recommended securities in an investment fund that was owned and promoted by her husband, a fact that was disclosed to her clients. However, the securities were sold without a prospectus … Continue Reading

OSC Second Guesses IIROC on Marc McQuillen Settlement Agreement and Northern Securities Penalties

Posted in Compliance and Supervision, Enforcement, IIROC, OSC

As we discussed in a previous post, the Ontario Securities Commission (OSC) rarely exercises its broad statutory discretion to interfere with and remake IIROC decisions. Last month, the OSC departed from this approach on two separate occasions.

First, in McQuillen, the OSC took the rare but not unprecedented step of setting aside as “manifestly unfair” a 2007 settlement agreement (the Agreement) between IIROC and Marc McQuillen (the Applicant). The OSC also ordered IIROC to expunge the Applicant’s related disciplinary record and to repay $25,000 in fines to the Applicant.

The Applicant entered into the … Continue Reading

OSC Shows Reluctance to Second Guess IIROC Panel in Northern Securities Decision

Posted in Compliance and Supervision, Enforcement, IIROC, OSC

Appeals to the Ontario Securities Commission from IIROC discipline panel decisions are relatively uncommon.  A decision released at the end of 2013 shows the heavy burdens faced by parties who initiate the hearing and review process at the OSC.

In Northern Securities Inc. et al[1], an IIROC member firm and certain of its officers appealed by way of hearing and review[2] the disciplinary decision of a three person hearing panel.  The OSC released reasons nine months after the OSC hearing.… Continue Reading